What is an index fund, and how is it different from an ETF?

by Charlie Sammonds

An index fund aims to track a market index, such as the S&P 500, rather than select investments individually. An exchange-traded fund, or ETF, is a type of fund traded on a stock exchange. Many ETFs track an index, but not every index fund is an ETF.


The short version

Index funds and ETFs aren’t necessarily alternatives. The terms describe different things:

  • Index fund describes what a fund does: it aims to track an index.
  • ETF describes a type of fund whose shares trade on an exchange.

Think of it like a recipe and a container. “Index fund” tells you the approach inside; “ETF” tells you how the fund is packaged and traded. One fund can be both.

The distinction matters because two funds can track the same market but differ in how you buy them, the fees you pay and the investment options available on your platform.


What does an index fund actually do?

An index is a collection of investments used to measure a market or part of one. The S&P 500, for example, tracks a selection of large US companies.

An index fund aims to follow its chosen index rather than have a manager pick investments in an attempt to beat it. Depending on its approach, a fund might hold all the investments in the index or use a representative sample.

That doesn’t mean its return will be exactly the same as the index. Fund charges and the mechanics of tracking can create a difference between the two, known as tracking difference. An index can also fall, so tracking it does not protect an investor from losses.


Index fund vs ETF: side by side

This table compares an index-tracking ETF with a traditional, non-exchange-traded index fund, such as a unit trust or open-ended investment company.

FeatureIndex-tracking ETFTraditional index fund
Buying and sellingTraded on an exchange during market hoursUsually bought and sold at a price calculated at a set valuation point, often once a day
Minimum investmentDepends on the provider, share price and availability of fractional investingDepends on the fund and provider; some accept small regular investments
Fund costsUsually has an ongoing charge; trading spreads may also applyUsually has an ongoing charge
ISA, SIPP or GIAEligible ETFs can be held in these accounts, depending on the providerEligible funds can be held in these accounts, depending on the provider
Dealing feesDepend on the provider and how you tradeDepend on the provider and fund

ETF prices can change throughout the trading day. The price you receive may differ from the value of the underlying assets. There’s also a difference between the price at which you can buy and sell, called the spread.

With a traditional fund, you typically place an instruction and receive the next applicable fund price. Check the provider’s dealing arrangements: the precise timing and costs vary.

For more on fund structures, read ETFs vs mutual funds and what is an ETF?


Are all ETFs index funds?

No. Many ETFs are passive funds that track an index, but some are actively managed. With an active ETF, a manager makes investment decisions rather than simply aiming to follow an index.

The ETF label alone doesn’t tell you the strategy. Check the fund’s objective, index and factsheet. Our active vs passive investing guide explains the difference.


Which one might suit you?

The answer depends on what you want to hold, how you plan to invest and the costs available to you.

  • A monthly saver may value an affordable regular-investing service and a low minimum investment. Either format could work, depending on the provider.
  • Someone investing a lump sum may want to compare the underlying holdings, total costs and dealing arrangements rather than choosing on format alone.
  • Someone who wants to see live prices may prefer the exchange-traded structure of an ETF. An intraday price doesn’t make the underlying investments less risky, though.

In each case, the investments inside the fund matter more than a label on its own. A broad index fund and a narrow sector tracker can have very different risk profiles.


What does it cost?

Both ETFs and traditional funds can have an ongoing charge, deducted within the fund. You may also pay platform fees, account charges or dealing fees. For an ETF, the spread can add to the cost of trading.

Compare the costs that apply to your actual account and investing pattern. A low fund charge is useful to know, but it isn’t the whole picture. Read our guide to ETF costs, TER and platform fees.


Worked example: £200 a month over 10 years

Suppose you invest £200 at the end of each month for 10 years, starting from £0. That’s £24,000 contributed in total.

For illustration, assume a steady 5% annual return before charges, with returns and a single combined annual percentage charge applied evenly through the year.

Assumed combined annual chargeIllustrative value after 10 years
0.20%£30,543
0.60%£29,897
Difference£646

Past performance does not guarantee future results.

The difference includes the effect of charges and the growth that could otherwise have been earned on money taken in charges. It is not a forecast or a comparison of specific providers.

The model assumes the same underlying return and no other costs, taxes or withdrawals. It excludes dealing fees, spreads and inflation. Real returns vary, charges may change and investments can lose value.


FAQs

Is an index fund safer than an ETF?

Not necessarily. An index fund can be an ETF, so the labels aren’t opposites. Risk depends mainly on what the fund holds, how concentrated it is and the risks of its underlying market—not just how it trades.

Can I hold an index fund in an ISA?

Yes, an eligible index fund can be held in a Stocks and Shares ISA if your provider offers it. Check the fund and account rules before investing.

Do index funds pay dividends?

Some do. A distributing share class pays income out; an accumulating share class generally reinvests it within the fund. The treatment depends on the fund and share class.


Takeaway

An index fund describes an investment approach. An ETF describes a way to package and trade a fund. To compare them, look past the labels and check the holdings, costs and account availability.

Capital at risk. The value of your investments can go down as well as up and you may get back less than you invest. ETFs carry costs, and their value can fall as well as rise. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in the future. This is general information, not personalised advice.

Click to rate this post!
Total: 0. Average: 0.

You may also like

Leave a Comment